Towing Cost vs Roadside Assistance: Full Comparison

Towing Cost vs Roadside Assistance: Full Comparison

Photo: Pexels

Quick Answer: Paying for a single tow out of pocket costs $75–$300. An annual roadside assistance plan costs $60–$130 and covers multiple tows plus jump starts, lockouts, and flat tires. If you drive more than occasionally, a plan wins financially after just one incident. The real question is whether you already have coverage through insurance or a credit card.

What To Do

  1. Audit your existing coverage before spending anything new. You may already be paying for roadside assistance through:
    • Auto insurance policy (look for “roadside” or “emergency road service” on your declarations page)
    • Credit card, call the number on the back and ask if roadside is included
    • Vehicle manufacturer program (new car? check the glove box for coverage documents)
    • Cell phone plan (some T-Mobile, Verizon plans include it)
  2. If you have no coverage, decide based on your situation:
    • Drive an older car that occasionally has issues? Get a plan.
    • Drive a new car rarely, mostly short local trips? Out-of-pocket may be fine.
    • Road trip regularly, drive in winter, or live in a rural area? A plan is essential.
  3. Compare roadside plans by your biggest risk:
    • Frequent long-distance driver: AAA Plus (100-mile tow coverage)
    • Local driving only: AAA Basic, or a credit card roadside benefit
    • Budget-conscious: Check if your insurer offers a roadside rider for $5–$15/year
  4. Factor in non-towing benefits. A jump start call through AAA costs nothing with membership. Out of pocket, a service call runs $50–$80. Lockouts and flat tire changes add up the same way.

What It Might Cost

Out-of-pocket towing (no coverage):

SituationCost
Local tow (under 10 miles)$75–$150
Mid-distance tow (10–30 miles)$150–$250
Long-distance tow (50+ miles)$300–$600
Jump start (service call)$50–$80
Lockout service$50–$100

Annual roadside assistance plans:

PlanAnnual CostTowing Coverage
AAA Basic$60–$805 miles free, 4 calls
AAA Plus$100–$130100 miles free, 4 calls
Better World Club Basic$58–$725 miles free
Insurance roadside rider$5–$15Varies by policy
Credit card roadside$0 extraPer-incident dispatch ~$50

Break-even math: AAA Basic at $75/year. If you use it once for a $120 tow, net cost is negative $45, you’re ahead. One jump start in addition covers two years of membership.

Stay Safe

  • Roadside plans are only useful if you actually call them. Store the number in your phone now.
  • AAA and most roadside apps (AAA, Allstate, Urgently) show real-time GPS tracking of your tow truck. Use this feature, it’s safer than stepping outside repeatedly to check.
  • If your situation involves a collision, call your insurance company first, the process for accident towing is different from breakdown towing.

Was this guide helpful?

Thanks for the feedback!

↑ Back to top